Bloody Mary
How does your garden grow?
With silver bells and cockleshells
And pretty maids all in a row.
The darkness is very real, though also wrapped in centuries of folklore and political propaganda.
According to one widely circulated interpretation, the rhyme is a veiled commentary on the violent reign of Queen Mary I of England, better known as Bloody Mary. The rhyme ties each innocent‑sounding garden image to tools of torture or execution used during her persecution of Protestants.
Mary, Mary, quite contrary
“Contrary” refers to Mary’s refusal to accept the Protestant reforms established by her father, Henry VIII. When she took the throne, she violently attempted to reverse the English Reformation and restore Catholicism.
How does your garden grow?
The “garden” is interpreted as a graveyard, filled with the bodies of Protestant martyrs executed under her rule. During her five‑year reign, hundreds were burned at the stake.
With silver bells and cockleshells
Silver bells are believed to refer to thumbscrews, a torture device used to crush fingers.
Cockleshells are thought to be genital torture clamps used on male prisoners.
These interpretations come from sources that frame the rhyme as a catalogue of torture instruments associated with Mary’s regime.
And pretty maids all in a row
Two major theories circulate:
Execution victims lined up for hanging or burning.
Or, more symbolically, the “maids” may refer to the Maiden, an early form of guillotine used in Scotland and sometimes associated with English executions.
Are these interpretations historically proven?
Not definitively.
Nursery rhymes often accumulate folklore explanations long after their creation, and scholars debate how literal these connections are. But the association with Bloody Mary is one of the most persistent and widely repeated.
What’s undeniable is that the rhyme’s imagery—bells, shells, maids—maps neatly onto the tools and consequences of Mary’s brutal campaign against Protestants. Whether intentional or retrofitted, the symbolism resonates.
Click below to find me: