Wednesday, December 12, 2018

About Book Reviews

Is having a lot of book reviews important?


There are a lot of posts circling on social sites among authors. Some seem to have insider information and saying that books that have less than 30-50 reviews are not shown as "related titles" or "inspired by your browsing history" and "customers who viewed this item also viewed."

Some authors report that, although their books have 50-100 or more reviews, they don't see any increase in sales increase or higher rank numbers.

The only thing seems to be true is that the BookBub promo service rejects books with less than 4 point rating and authors report that they reject books with less than 50 reviews as well.

As an author, when a reader posts a review on my books, it's like getting a gift and a needed ego boost to continue writing.

However, as a reader, I'm guilty of not reading as many books as I would love to and not writing as many reviews as I should because I just don't have the time.

When I have time to read, I choose Indie books to support self-published authors and small publishers. But because I have a lot of author friends or belong to groups with the authors on social sites, my reviews often viewed by the Zon as biased and rejected.

I can understand it though because there are a lot of desperate authors out there who would do anything to get reviews. I see many posts on social sites offering review exchange, so no wonder Amazon views every review that is written by a published author suspicious.

Paid reviews are a big no-no.

What is considered payment for a review?

A free book is considered payment by Amazon, so book review bloggers are required to post disclaimers when they review a book they received from the author or publisher. This means a free book must be given before the review is posted with no specifications about what kind of or favorable review must be written.

Amazon also does not permit reviews (or even votes on reviews) to be posted in exchange for any kind of compensation including entry to a contest or sweepstakes, discounts on future purchases, extra products, or other gifts.

No gifts should be given after the review is written, so there’s no appearance of payment for a positive review. If you do offer a free or discounted product in exchange for a review, you need to make it clear that you welcome both positive and negative feedback.

Reviews that come from a paid blog tour are not eligible as customer reviews. I never did a paid blog tour, so I never knew that if you do, you can only quote from the reviews in the “editorial reviews” section of your book.

Trading reviews between authors is strictly forbidden such as “I’ll give you a five star if you give me one” No author should review another with the expectation that the review will be reciprocated.

Some unscrupulous authors may even blackmail others which happened to me once when my book was on countdown sale for 99 cents.
I got a message on my FB page saying, “I gave you a 5-star review. My book is 99 cents, here is the link. If you don't post a 5-star review for me, I’ll change my review to a one-star.”
I was livid and replied, "Judging by the few words you posted, it's obvious that you didn't read my book. This is blackmail, and if you don't delete your review, I will report you to Amazon." Luckily, he just deleted the review or maybe Amazon did, I'll never know.
Don’t fall for or get intimidated by blackmailers. If they do change their rating to one star, the best is to report them to Amazon.

Some believe that no author should be allowed to write a review, but this is an unrealistic expectation. Authors read too, and as readers, they have all the rights to voice their opinion honestly and in an unbiased manner.

I suspect it but I'm not sure about this. I love to read the genres which I love to write, speculative historical fiction with magical elements and suspense. I noticed that when I post a review of books in those genres, it gets rejected as well as my reviews of children's books. I'm just guessing because I write children's books too. However, when I reviewed poetry or non-fiction, the Zon left it alone.

When reviewing books in your own genre or sub-genre or any author's work who might be considered “a competitor”, Amazon’s TOS say “You may not write reviews for products or services that you have a financial interest in, including reviews for products or services that you or your competitors sell.

What is your opinion about book reviews?



COMMENTS

13 comments
Add a comment

Stream

Cindy Smith

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
Amazon's policy is terrible.  Reviews for any book that is purchased should be allowed and as far as I am concerned, any written for a book given by the author should not be allowed.  Some people only review books they have been given and to be sure they keep getting more they are usually so glowing that when I read the same book I wonder what drugs they were taking when they read it!
+
1
2
1
 
 · 
Reply
 
I totally agree Cindy!

Cindy Smith shared this via Google+

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
+
1
2
1
 
 · 
Reply

Ruth de Jauregui via Google+

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
Erika M. Szabo​ shares a post about the importance of reviews and the guidelines for posting them on Amazon. An amazing and informative article on #OurAuthorGang today!!
+
1
2
1
 
 · 
Reply

Tricia Drammeh

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
Interesting post, Erika. Book reviews have become overly-complicated. I understand why Amazon has to have rules, but they seem to be inconsistent and confusing in many cases. I think all the rules and confusion have scared people away from reviewing, which is a shame. Like you said, one review can really boost an author's self-esteem. Plus, reviews are helpful for consumers.
+
1
2
1
 
 · 
Reply
 
The rules are very confusing and vague. When I published my first book it was a lot more simple. You purchased a book and if you wanted, posted a review. Now with all this cheating and people making it a business to write reviews, it turned into a nightmare.

Ruth de Jauregui

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
Great post Erika! Reviews are important, especially for new authors.

One thing I'd recommend to Facebook users -- Lock down your friends list so nobody can see who your friends are (unless they're both friended with you, then they can see each other) and be very careful who you add as a friend. This also helps cut down on scammers and fake profile friend requests. LOL, they won't stop, but they'll slow down.
+
1
2
1
 
 · 
Reply
 
Great advice Ruth!

Eva Pasco

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
You covered a lot of ground on the subject.
+
3
4
3
 
 · 
Reply
 
It is unnecessarily complicated. Amazon created a monster and now trying to deal with it with stricter rules that punishes honest authors as well

Chris Weigand shared this via Google+

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
+
2
3
2
 
 · 
Reply

Toi Thomas via Google+

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
Today, Erika M. Szabo​ offers some thought-provoking questions and concerns about book reviews. #OurAuthorGang
+
2
3
2
 
 · 
Reply

Erika M Szabo shared this via Google+

1 month ago  -  Shared publicly
 
+
2
3
2
 
 · 
Reply

Featured Post

Online Magazines